Best Ice Cream In Charlotte? – Seemingly Overzealous To Open In Camp North End

Best Ice Cream In Charlotte? – Seemingly Overzealous To Open In Camp North End

Seemingly Overzealous - Where To Get Ice Cream In Charlotte

The competition for best ice cream in Charlotte is heating up! Will Seemingly Overzealous opening in Camp North End be a competitor for this title. We will find out later this season!

Seemingly Overzealous was founded by partners Garrett Tichy and Jessica Berresse, who met in 2020 and connected over ice cream. Their first date included taste testing an ice cream flight – complete with flavors from different ice cream shops in Charlotte, as well as one created at home by Tichy as part of a new pandemic-era hobby. As their relationship grew, so did the business, which has transformed from sharing leftovers with friends to selling to the public online.

With no dietary restrictions themselves, Tichy and Berresse are focused on creating dairy-free ice cream that can be enjoyed by all without sacrificing on quality.

photos by Remy Thurston

Customers can expect both the standard flavors they love, like mint chocolate chip and vanilla, as well as more unconventional flavor options such as blood orange carrot ginger, banana pecan maple, matcha with honey and lemon, peanut butter & jelly, and much more. Flavors will rotate on a monthly basis and the funkier the better – including their corresponding names, which are derived from the founders’ personal experiences.

The couple collaborated with creative director and designer, Pablo Agurcia, to bring their vision for Seemingly Overzealous to life. Agurcia’s thoughtful branding and design work will serve as the foundation and inspiration for the experience customers can expect from the storefront. Working with architecture, design, and interiors firm Quin Gwinn Studio, the new 700-square-foot permanent location will include space for both kitchen and retail areas and feature a colorful palette. Branding firm Mad Goat Studio is also creating an interactive element for customers, in which each cup and pint will feature a QR code that leads to a question to spark conversation.

The name ‘Seemingly Overzealous’ is a nod to their early beginnings as a couple. Putting aside their fears of ‘seeming overzealous’ in the early days of their relationship created space for them to really get to know each other.

In addition to this concept, Tichy is also the founder and owner of Charlotte-based co-working company hygge, which has operated a 10,000 square-foot location at Camp North End since 2017. As part of the company’s continued expansion, just last month, hygge acquired Advent Coworking, bringing its total locations to five and growing its membership base to 800.

Seemingly Overzealous’ new location is part of phase II of the development, which includes the adaptive reuse of 701 Keswick Avenue and 201 Camp Road into Class A office and retail, as well as the addition of new multifamily and a parking garage. Construction on the office, retail and parking garage portions are anticipated to be completed in June 2022, while the multifamily component is expected to begin construction in 2022 and be completed in 2024.

This builds on January’s announcement that Best Impressions Caterers has finalized a long-term lease at 701 Keswick to create The Revelry North End, a brand-new 600-seat, 23,000-square-foot special event venue.

For more information about Camp North End, visit the official Camp North End website at or follow along on Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, and LinkedIn at @campnorthend.

Read More: